Humm, we went through one smokercraft and two michicrafts before we switched to fiberglass/royalex/kevlar. I have one of each. Which do you like better and why: Grumman or Alumacraft? I think both are well made. If you want to put a square-stern on the water, your paddling skills will be totally transferable, so it’s not like you have to learn the basic strokes all over again.
This versatile, light-weight and multi-purpose canoe has been perfectly adapted for those wanting to also fish and hunt. What you need to do is figure out which size suits you best e.g. We have a 1973 Grumman Standard 17'. Even heavily laden, it can still be pushed along with a 5 HP motor (the manufacturer’s suggested limit). visitors a day during peak season.
The ‘Bulb T keel’, adds stability to the canoe, even with an outboard put on the back. Thinking of making a trip to the BW 6 November, Sept/ Oct 7-day Trip - YouTube Slide Show - South Kawishiwi Entry. The Grumman 17 double end is far less stable than the 17 Alumacraft, unless you load it with about 200 pounds of rock.
This style of canoe has the added advantage of being a lot sturdier than other types on the market, mostly because there is an added support laid into the hull that increases the overall stability and strength of a longer canoe. This boat is cleverly designed with full-length stabilizing chines and a generous beam, making it a comfortable ride no matter the situation.
Having paddled that and a bunch of rental and Scout camp boats, my preference is definitely for Grumman over Alumacraft. 17'-might be called voyageur ultralight? The manufacture of your canoe will recommend the maximum power of the trolling motor that best suits your canoe (typically 4hp), so make sure you follow these guidelines when looking for the bolting plate and motor size. I may have paddled a Grumman once or twice at most in my life. But which model or style do you choose? Wade into your next outdoor adventure with a reliable canoe from DICK'S Sporting Goods. Easily the best $100 I have ever spent.
:) Alumacraft and Grumman are both good boats! Learn more. I decided to weigth it and it weighted 85 pounds. More objectively, the construction of Grummans is better, such as how they're riveted and how the different pieces come together. * For the benefit of the community, commercial posting is not allowed. There is a great level of versatility with this boat, with a huge carrying capacity and the added benefit of being insulated from the cold water, allowing you to be out in the wild and still get to your favourite fishing spots throughout the colder season. I like the way it's constructed with the smooth, no-rivet hull and the good stability.
This hand-crafted canoe is made from special age-hardened, stretch-formed aluminium alloy and far longer than a lot of models on the market. This is a nice, long and well designed square stern in Old Town’s range of boats. Follow the "Live Social Media" Feed from Grummans were all I ever used in my early Quetico area trips as a teenager. Alumacraft 17 foot double end, which is more stable than a Grumman double end.
mine looks like it was harpooned hence its alternative nickname the gray whale. Our boats range from pro bass and bay fishing boats to versatile utility/ jon boats for hunting and hauling. You can use this style of canoe like any other traditional canoes on the market, but you have the added benefit of taking it easy when using a tolling motor. My aluminum canoe is an Alumacraft which I've used/had since the mid-60's. Most manufactures will only advise you to use a motor with a maximum of 4hp and only use on water that won’t require you to keep the engine revving all the time.
They were great canoes, but I'm too old to carry that kind of weight over my shoulders, so I carry it on my belly. It had a low bow and stern profile, not those huge recurved ends that catch the wind, and was just as sturdy as any other Grumman. For someone a bit taller maybe it wouldn't be an issue, but for me and the way I paddle it's a total dealbreaker. Forgot your password? Choose from top brands Old Town Canoe, Sun Dolphin and more. This version of Grumman’s square-stern canoes is ideal for those wanting a larger model. My first canoe was a Grumman 17 Eagle, actually one of Grumman's best models (tell us why you think it's a POS, canoepaddle). You can even get the interior of the canoe painted in camo to help with fitting into the environment and opt for wooden gunwales too. TGO-i bought mine from spring creek about 6 years ago best $325 i ever spent!
Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness (BWCAW). Find Alumacraft Canoe in Boats For Sale in Madison, WI. A square-stern canoe may look a bit odd to some people and hard for the more traditional-canoe fans to appreciate, but in so many ways, this style has a huge advantage whilst on certain paddling trips and specific paddling experiences. Canoes For Your Next Lakeside Adventure. The reason comes down to details of design and workmanship. This smallest model can still comfortably house three adults and is still a relatively lightweight when un-laden (95lbs).
Being a longer canoe, it does help that this is robust and stronger due to the shape and material used to make it. I've found the Grumman's to have a slightly better shape than the Alumacrafts for performance in the water for me, although that's totally subjective. This is Sun Dolphin’s more ‘specialised’ canoe range. The ‘Bulb T keel’, adds stability to the canoe, even with an outboard put on the back.
Key aspects to think about when choosing a square-stern canoe is that you can use a motor when going on long journeys or when you want a break, but the obvious disadvantage is the slightly more tricky shape to tie down on a rack or trailer. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Having the square stern allows for motors to be mounted, but still gives a nice balance on the water.
I may be mistaken but it seems to me that when I got it the weight was listed for the Quetico Q17 at 69 lbs. You also want to consider where the stern seat is located in relation to the trolling motor mounting plate, as some models do need you to reach quite far back to get to the motor’s controls. On one trip we took out one of each and no matter what paddler/pack combination we tried, the Grumman paddled like a barge compared to the Alumacraft. Don't have an account yet? do you need more storage capacity, or do you need a smaller canoe so that you can also solo-paddle easier. Neither with a flat back though.
The ‘bulb keel’ helps paddlers because of the added stability and creates a stiffer and stronger hull. Alumacraft Voyageur 17 aluminum canoe with paddles: Length 17', Beam 36", Height 12" Weight about 56lbs *not sure the mfg year*4 person or 650 lb capacity100% WATER TIGHT NO LEAKSSome scratches and dings from normal use (see pics)... sturdy and well-built and will provide many years of fishing and fun